A California court may issue domestic violence restraining orders against both parties, but mutual orders require strict safeguards. The court cannot simply restrain everyone because both parties accuse each other of misconduct.

Each Party Must Make a Separate Request

Each person seeking protection must file their own request and give the other party proper notice. Merely denying the allegations and describing abuse in a response does not automatically place a separate restraining-order request before the court.

This requirement ensures that each person knows they may become subject to an order and has a fair opportunity to respond.

Both Parties Must Present Evidence of Abuse

Mutual orders require evidence supporting a finding that each party committed qualifying abuse. Conflicting accusations alone are not enough.

The court evaluates the alleged incidents, the history of the relationship, credibility, supporting records, and the overall circumstances.

The Court Must Evaluate Aggression and Self-Defense

Before issuing mutual orders, the court must make detailed findings that both parties acted as primary aggressors and that neither acted primarily in self-defense.

The primary aggressor is the dominant aggressor, not necessarily the person who acted first during a particular encounter. Conduct that appears aggressive in isolation may have occurred in reasonable self-defense.

Competing Requests Should Be Coordinated

When both parties have pending requests, having them heard together can reduce the risk of inconsistent orders. The court should be informed promptly if related restraining-order cases or other protective orders exist.

Until the court rules, each temporary order remains binding according to its own terms.

A California domestic violence attorney can prepare a separate request, present the relationship history, address self-defense, and identify the primary aggressor. Mutual DVROs are not an automatic compromise; they require evidence and specific factual findings.

CATEGORIES:

Uncategorized

Tags:

Comments are closed

Latest Comments

No comments to show.