Mutual domestic violence restraining orders are not appropriate merely because both parties accuse each other of misconduct. California imposes strict requirements before a court may restrain both people under competing DVROs.
Each Party Must File a Separate Request
A response denying the other person’s allegations is not enough to obtain affirmative protective relief. Each person seeking a DVRO must file their own request and provide notice that they are asking the court to restrain the other party.
This requirement gives both parties a fair opportunity to understand and respond to the allegations. The court cannot transform a defense into a separate restraining-order request without the required procedure.
Both Parties Must Present Evidence of Abuse
The court must find evidence supporting each request. Conflicting testimony or a generally unhealthy relationship does not automatically establish that both individuals committed legally recognized abuse.
Messages, recordings, photographs, police records, witness testimony, and the parties’ accounts may be relevant. The court evaluates credibility and the totality of the circumstances.
The Court Must Examine Aggression and Self-Defense
Before issuing mutual orders, the court must make detailed findings that both parties acted as primary aggressors and that neither acted primarily in self-defense. The primary aggressor means the dominant aggressor, not necessarily the person who acted first during one incident.
The analysis considers the history of domestic violence, threats creating fear of injury, the protective purpose of the law, and whether either person used reasonable force to defend themselves or another person.
Competing Cases Should Be Coordinated
When both parties file DVRO requests, the matters should ordinarily be brought before the same judicial officer so the evidence and required findings can be considered together. Separate hearing dates can create inconsistent custody, property, or contact orders.
Until the court reconciles the cases, every existing TRO remains binding according to its terms. Neither party may choose which order to follow based on personal preference.
A California domestic violence attorney can prepare or respond to the separate requests, present the relationship history and self-defense evidence, and seek coordinated orders that avoid conflicting obligations.


Comments are closed