Legal separation in California is an option for couples who wish to live apart but do not want to divorce. A legal separation allows spouses to live separately and address important issues like property division, spousal support, and child custody, without formally dissolving the marriage. This process can be a useful alternative to divorce for individuals who may not be ready to fully end the marriage but need to live apart for various personal, financial, or religious reasons.
California law provides a framework for legal separation, which is governed by the California Family Code. This comprehensive legal structure ensures that both parties can receive protection and clarity on issues related to their relationship while still remaining married. This essay will provide an in-depth exploration of the legal separation process in California, including the grounds for legal separation, how it differs from divorce, the benefits of legal separation, and the procedures involved.
1. What is Legal Separation?
Legal separation is a court-approved arrangement in which married couples live apart and settle key issues related to the marriage. Unlike divorce, where the marriage is legally ended, legal separation does not terminate the marital relationship. The couple remains legally married, but they are living separately, and the court may issue orders regarding spousal support, child custody, and property division.
While legal separation does not dissolve the marriage, it offers a way for individuals to gain clarity on financial and familial obligations while living apart. Legal separation is commonly chosen for various reasons, including:
- Religious beliefs: Some individuals may choose legal separation because their religion prohibits divorce.
- Financial reasons: Legal separation allows spouses to remain married, which may have financial advantages, such as continued health insurance coverage through a spouse’s employer.
- Trial period: Couples may use legal separation as a “trial run” before deciding whether to proceed with divorce.
- Legal status: Some people may not be ready to dissolve their marriage legally but wish to address critical issues like child custody and property division.
2. Grounds for Legal Separation in California
In California, the grounds for legal separation are similar to those for divorce. California is a no-fault state, meaning that neither party is required to prove fault or wrongdoing to obtain a legal separation. Instead, a spouse can request legal separation based on the following grounds:
- Irreconcilable differences: The marriage is broken to the point where reconciliation is not possible. This is the most common ground for both divorce and legal separation in California.
- Incurable insanity: One spouse has been diagnosed with an incurable mental illness, and the condition has made the marriage unworkable. This ground is rarely used in legal separation cases.
Unlike divorce, where one spouse must seek the dissolution of the marriage, legal separation may be requested by either spouse, and both must agree to the terms of the separation. However, if one spouse files for legal separation and the other contests it, the court may require the couple to proceed to a divorce if there are no reasonable grounds for the separation.
3. Legal Separation vs. Divorce: Key Differences
Although legal separation and divorce share some similarities, they are distinct legal processes. Below is a comparison of legal separation and divorce in California:
| Aspect | Legal Separation | Divorce |
|---|---|---|
| Marital Status | The couple remains legally married. | The marriage is dissolved; spouses are legally single. |
| Property Division | Property division is handled, but spouses remain married. | Property is divided as part of the divorce process. |
| Spousal Support | Spousal support (alimony) can be awarded. | Spousal support (alimony) can be awarded. |
| Child Custody and Support | Child custody and support are determined. | Child custody and support are determined. |
| Healthcare and Benefits | Spouses may continue to receive benefits, such as health insurance, through one spouse’s employer. | The possibility of continuing benefits is generally limited after divorce. |
| Ability to Remarry | Spouses cannot remarry, as the marriage is still legally intact. | Spouses can remarry once the divorce is finalized. |
| Religious Considerations | Often chosen for religious reasons to avoid divorce. | Divorce may not be permissible for those with strict religious views. |
4. Benefits of Legal Separation
There are several reasons why couples may choose legal separation over divorce. Some of the most common reasons include:
- Maintaining Benefits: In some cases, staying legally married allows one spouse to continue receiving certain benefits, such as health insurance, social security, or pension benefits, from the other spouse’s employment or government benefits. Divorce typically results in the loss of these benefits.
- Religious Reasons: Some couples may prefer legal separation over divorce for religious or moral reasons. In many faiths, divorce is not permitted or is highly discouraged. Legal separation allows couples to live apart without violating these religious beliefs.
- Financial Considerations: Couples may choose legal separation to retain certain financial advantages. For example, if one spouse needs access to the other spouse’s health insurance or tax benefits, staying married through legal separation might be a more practical option. Furthermore, some couples may face financial hardship and prefer to maintain the status quo of their marriage without going through a costly divorce.
- Trial Separation: Legal separation can serve as a trial period for a couple considering divorce. It provides the opportunity to live apart and evaluate the future of the relationship without the finality of divorce. During this time, spouses can address issues such as custody, property division, and spousal support.
- Protection for Children: Legal separation allows parents to make arrangements for child custody and support while still being married. This provides legal protections for both parents and children in the event that the marriage is not legally dissolved.
5. The Legal Separation Process in California
The process for obtaining a legal separation in California is similar to that of divorce. The following steps outline the typical process:
Step 1: Filing the Petition for Legal Separation
To begin the legal separation process, one spouse (the petitioner) must file a Petition for Legal Separation with the California family court. The petition must include information about the marriage, such as:
- The names and addresses of both spouses
- The date of marriage and the date of separation
- Requests for property division, spousal support, child custody, and child support
The petition is typically filed in the county where the spouse filing for separation resides. In California, there are residency requirements that must be met before filing. One spouse must have lived in the state for at least six months, and in the county where the petition is filed, for at least three months.
Step 2: Serving the Petition
After the petition is filed, the petitioner must serve the other spouse (the respondent) with a copy of the petition. Service can be done in several ways, including personal delivery, mail, or service by a third party.
Once the respondent has been served, they have a specified period (usually 30 days) to file a Response with the court. If the respondent agrees with the separation, the process may proceed smoothly, but if the respondent disagrees or contests any of the terms, the case may become more complicated.
Step 3: Negotiation and Settlement
Like divorce, legal separation often involves negotiation between the spouses to settle issues such as:
- Child Custody and Support: Both parents must agree on custody arrangements and child support payments. If the parents cannot agree, the court will make a decision based on the child’s best interests.
- Property Division: Property acquired during the marriage must be divided, and the spouses must agree on how to divide their assets and debts.
- Spousal Support: If applicable, spousal support may be determined based on factors such as the length of the marriage, the financial needs of each spouse, and the ability of the paying spouse to provide support.
In many cases, couples can reach an agreement through negotiation, mediation, or collaborative law, which avoids the need for court intervention.
Step 4: Court Hearing and Final Judgment
If the spouses agree on the terms of the separation, they can submit a Stipulated Judgment to the court for approval. Once approved, the court will issue a final judgment of legal separation, which formalizes the arrangement.
If the spouses cannot reach an agreement, the court will hold a hearing to resolve the contested issues. The judge will issue orders regarding property division, spousal support, and child custody, among other matters. Once the judge issues these orders, the legal separation is final.
6. After Legal Separation
Once a legal separation is finalized, both spouses are still legally married and cannot remarry. However, they will have a clear understanding of their rights and obligations under the separation, including any orders for spousal support, child custody, and property division.
If either spouse later decides they want a divorce, they can file for dissolution of marriage. The separation agreements and court orders made during the legal separation process can be used in the divorce proceedings.
Conclusion
Legal separation in California is a useful option for couples who wish to live apart but do not want to divorce. It provides a structured way to resolve key issues such as property division, spousal support, and child custody, without ending the marriage. Legal separation offers flexibility and protection for those who have religious, financial, or personal reasons for remaining married. While it differs from divorce in that it does not legally terminate the marriage, legal separation can provide significant clarity and structure during a time of transition.
Law Offices of James R. Dickinson – 909-848-8448
How To Schedule A Consultation:
Please call us at 909-848-8448 to schedule a free consultation/case evaluation or complete the form immediately below. [Please note certain formalities must be completed to retain the Law Offices of James R. Dickinson, such as the signing of a legal fee agreement [see “Disclaimers”]].