In a California personal injury case involving uneven flooring transitions in a retail store, the store may be liable for injuries caused by these hazardous conditions under premises liability law. Uneven floors, especially at transitions between different types of flooring (e.g., tile to carpet, wood to tile), are common causes of trip-and-fall accidents, and businesses have a legal duty to ensure their premises are safe for customers.
⚖️ Premises Liability in California (Civil Code § 1714)
Under California Civil Code § 1714, property owners, including retail stores, must maintain their premises in a reasonably safe condition for the people who visit their stores. If uneven flooring or transitions between different flooring types are not properly managed, they could be considered a dangerous condition that leads to accidents.
✅ Key Elements to Prove in an Uneven Flooring Injury Case
To succeed in a personal injury case involving uneven flooring transitions, the injured party must show:
1. Duty of Care
The store has a legal duty to keep its premises safe for customers. This includes:
- Ensuring flooring transitions are level and free from hazards.
- Fixing defects in flooring that create dangerous tripping conditions.
- Properly maintaining floors and transitions to prevent accidents.
2. Breach of Duty
The store breaches its duty if:
- The uneven transition between floors is large enough to pose a risk of tripping or falling.
- The store failed to repair the flooring or warn customers about the hazard.
- The store didn’t use proper signage or barriers to prevent people from walking in areas where there are floor defects.
3. Causation
You must prove that the uneven flooring transition directly caused your injury. This means the uneven floor was the direct reason you tripped, fell, and got hurt.
4. Damages
You need to show that the injury caused actual harm, including:
- Medical expenses (e.g., doctor visits, surgery, physical therapy)
- Lost wages due to inability to work
- Pain and suffering from the injury
- Disability or other permanent consequences
🔍 Evidence to Strengthen Your Case
To support your claim and prove that the uneven floor transition caused the injury, gather the following evidence:
1. Photographs or Videos:
- Take clear photos of the uneven transition, documenting the height difference between the flooring types and how it created a tripping hazard.
- If possible, take pictures showing the lack of warning signs or barriers near the uneven flooring area.
2. Witness Statements:
- Witnesses (other customers, employees, or bystanders) who saw the fall or noticed the uneven floor should provide statements to support your case.
3. Incident Report:
- If the store documented the incident in an accident report, obtain a copy to help support your version of the events.
4. Surveillance Footage:
- Security camera footage from the store may capture the uneven flooring and the fall. If available, it can serve as powerful evidence.
5. Maintenance Records:
- Request the store’s maintenance records to determine whether the store had knowledge of the flooring issue and failed to repair it or address it in a timely manner.
6. Medical Records:
- Provide documentation of your injuries, treatment, and recovery timeline. Medical records will be necessary to show the extent of your injuries and the financial impact.
🛡️ Common Defenses the Store May Use
The store may attempt to reduce or deny liability by using the following defenses:
1. The Hazard Was Open and Obvious:
The store may argue that the uneven transition was visible and obvious, so you should have noticed it and avoided it. However, this defense is less likely to succeed if the transition was poorly marked, located in a high-traffic area, or the store had poor lighting.
2. The Store Didn’t Have Enough Time to Repair It:
If the floor defect was recent, the store may claim they did not have time to address it. In this case, they must demonstrate that they acted quickly once they became aware of the hazard.
3. You Were Not Paying Attention:
The store might argue that your own carelessness or inattention led to the fall. For example, they may claim you were distracted or not looking where you were walking. This could reduce your damages under California’s comparative negligence rule.
⚠️ Comparative Negligence in California
California follows pure comparative negligence, meaning if you’re partially responsible for the injury, your damages will be reduced in proportion to your percentage of fault.
For example:
- Total damages: $50,000
- You are found 20% at fault (e.g., not paying attention to where you were walking)
- You would recover $40,000.
🗓️ Statute of Limitations
In California, you generally have 2 years from the date of the injury to file a personal injury lawsuit.
💡 Factors That Strengthen Your Case
You likely have a strong case if:
- The uneven flooring had been present for a long period and was visible but not addressed by the store.
- The store had prior complaints or knowledge of the issue but failed to fix it.
- The store did not post any warnings or use barriers to alert customers about the flooring hazard.
- You sustained serious injuries, such as broken bones, sprains, or head injuries.
📋 Steps to Take After the Incident
- Report the accident to store management and ask for an incident report.
- Document the hazardous floor by taking photos or videos of the uneven transition and the surrounding area.
- Seek immediate medical attention to assess the extent of your injuries and document the treatment you received.
- Get witness contact information from anyone who saw the fall or the uneven flooring.
- Request surveillance footage of the accident if it happened in an area with cameras.
- Consult with a personal injury attorney.
Law Offices of James R. Dickinson – 909-848-8448
How To Schedule A Consultation:
Please call us at 909-848-8448 to schedule a free consultation/case evaluation or complete the form immediately below. [Please note certain formalities must be completed to retain the Law Offices of James R. Dickinson, such as the signing of a legal fee agreement [see “Disclaimers”]].