California courts generally value community assets and liabilities as close as practical to trial. When that timing would create an unfair result, however, the court may select an alternate date after separation and before trial.
Trial-Time Valuation Is the Starting Point
Using a date near trial ordinarily captures the asset’s most current value. This approach commonly applies to real estate, investment accounts, businesses, and other property that changes in value.
Current appraisals, account statements, market data, and debt balances may therefore be necessary.
Good Cause Is Required for Another Date
A party seeking an alternate valuation date must explain why trial-time valuation would produce an inequitable division. The court has discretion to accept or reject the proposed date.
The request should identify the affected assets and the specific date sought rather than assuming one date must apply to the entire estate.
Postseparation Efforts May Affect the Decision
An alternate date may be appropriate when a business’s value depends heavily on one spouse’s personal work, skill, reputation, or management after separation.
The court may also consider whether one spouse dissipated an asset, caused an unusual increase or decrease, or failed to maintain records needed for a current valuation.
The Valuation Date Can Materially Change the Division
A business, investment, or other asset may be worth substantially more or less at separation than at trial. Selecting the date can therefore affect both the value assigned and the equalizing payment required.
The parties should determine the valuation date before experts complete expensive appraisal work whenever possible.
A California property-division attorney can identify assets suitable for alternate valuation, obtain appropriate expert evidence, and explain why the requested date produces a fair division. The result depends on good cause and the specific history of the asset.


Comments are closed