Cracked sidewalks in residential areas can absolutely lead to a personal injury claim in California, but the success of such a case depends heavily on:
- Who owns or is responsible for the sidewalk
- The severity of the crack or defect
- Whether the responsible party had notice and failed to fix it
- Whether the crack is considered “trivial” under California law
🧱 Cracked Sidewalk Trip-and-Fall – California Law Overview
🔹 1. Can You Sue for a Sidewalk Trip in a Residential Area?
Yes, but only if you can prove that the crack was more than just a minor imperfection and that someone was negligent in failing to maintain it.
🔹 2. Who Is Responsible?
This depends on where the sidewalk is located:
âś… Public Sidewalk (in front of a home):
- In many California cities, the adjacent property owner (i.e., the homeowner) is responsible for sidewalk maintenance—even though the city owns the land.
- Some cities (like Los Angeles and San Francisco) may be liable only if they failed to inspect or repair a known hazard.
âś… Private Walkways (within apartment or condo complexes):
- The landlord, HOA, or property manager is typically responsible.
🔹 3. Legal Standard: Premises Liability
To succeed, you must prove:
- Dangerous Condition: The crack was wide, raised, or otherwise hazardous.
- Notice:
- The responsible party knew or should have known about it.
- Negligence:
- They failed to repair or warn despite having time or a duty to inspect.
- Injury: You suffered an injury as a direct result of the condition.
🔹 4. Trivial Defect Doctrine
- California courts may dismiss a case if the crack is considered “trivial” (typically under ¾ of an inch in height).
- However, if other factors exist—like shadows, poor lighting, or uneven slabs—a defect that might otherwise be “trivial” can still be found dangerous.
🔹 5. Claims Against a City (Government Entity)
- You must file a claim with the city within 6 months of the injury.
- You must show the city:
- Knew or should have known about the dangerous condition
- Failed to act within a reasonable time
- That the sidewalk posed a substantial risk of injury
🔹 6. Evidence That Helps
- Photos of the crack with measurements (ruler, coin, or shoe for scale)
- Witness statements
- Incident report filed with the city or HOA (if applicable)
- Medical records of your injury
- Maintenance or complaint history, if available
🔹 7. Damages You Can Recover
- Medical bills (including ongoing treatment)
- Lost wages
- Pain and suffering
- Long-term impairment (if applicable)
đź•’ Time Limits
| Type of Property | Time to Sue |
|---|---|
| Private homeowner/landlord | 2 years from date of injury |
| Public sidewalk (government claim) | 6 months to file a claim, or the case is barred |
âś… Example:
You trip on a 2-inch raised crack in a residential sidewalk that’s been that way for months. The city or homeowner knew (or should have known) about it, but didn’t fix it. You suffer a broken ankle. You likely have a strong claim.
Law Offices of James R. Dickinson – 909-848-8448
How To Schedule A Consultation:
Please call us at 909-848-8448 to schedule a free consultation/case evaluation or complete the form immediately below. [Please note certain formalities must be completed to retain the Law Offices of James R. Dickinson, such as the signing of a legal fee agreement [see “Disclaimers”]].