In a California personal injury case where Driver A turns left across traffic and is hit by an oncoming vehicle (likely Driver B), determining fault will depend on the specifics of the accident, including whether Driver A properly yielded to Driver B, whether they had a legal right of way, and whether either party acted negligently. In California, the law typically gives Driver B (the oncoming driver) the right of way, but certain facts could impact the analysis.
Here’s how the case might unfold:
🚗 Legal Considerations in a Left Turn Collision
- Right of Way and California Vehicle Code:
- Driver A is required to yield the right of way to oncoming traffic when making a left turn. Under California Vehicle Code § 21801, a driver making a left turn across traffic must yield to all vehicles approaching from the opposite direction, unless they have a green arrow or a protected left turn signal.
- If Driver A did not yield the right of way to Driver B, then Driver A could be considered at fault for the collision.
- However, if there was a green light or arrow for Driver A, they may have had the legal right to turn and could argue that Driver B was speeding or did not maintain a safe distance.
- Driver A’s Duty to Ensure Safety:
- Driver A has a duty to ensure the turn is safe. This means Driver A must wait for a safe gap in oncoming traffic and ensure that Driver B is not too close or speeding.
- If Driver A failed to assess the traffic conditions properly before making the turn (e.g., turning without sufficient time to clear the intersection), Driver A could be found negligent for making an unsafe maneuver.
- Driver B’s Responsibility:
- Driver B has a duty to maintain a safe speed and be alert while driving, especially when approaching an intersection.
- If Driver B was speeding, running a red light, or not paying attention (e.g., distracted driving), they could share or be entirely responsible for the accident, depending on the situation.
- If Driver B was within the posted speed limit and did not have the opportunity to stop or slow down due to Driver A’s failure to yield, then Driver B will likely have a solid case for being not at fault.
💼 Possible Claims and Damages for the Injured Party
If Driver A or their passengers were injured in the collision, they may be entitled to various forms of compensation:
- Medical Expenses:
- The injured party can claim compensation for the cost of emergency care, hospital bills, surgical procedures, physical therapy, and any ongoing medical treatment needed due to the injuries sustained.
- Pain and Suffering:
- Non-economic damages to compensate for the pain and emotional suffering caused by the accident, including any physical limitations or disabilities that result from the crash.
- Lost Wages:
- Compensation for lost income due to missed work while recovering from injuries. This could include future lost wages if the injuries are severe and have a long-term impact on the ability to work.
- Property Damage:
- Compensation for the repair or replacement of the damaged vehicle, as well as any other property damage that may have occurred during the accident.
- Punitive Damages:
- Punitive damages could be awarded if Driver B was found to have engaged in particularly reckless behavior (e.g., speeding excessively, driving under the influence, or intentionally ignoring traffic signals). These damages are designed to punish the wrongdoer and deter similar actions.
🧾 Evidence to Support the Claim
To support the case, the following types of evidence could be valuable:
- Police Report:
- The police report will document the details of the accident, including citations issued (e.g., if Driver A failed to yield) and any witness statements. This will also outline any traffic violations that may have contributed to the crash.
- Witness Statements:
- Witnesses who saw the crash or were nearby may be able to testify about Driver A’s actions (whether they yielded to oncoming traffic) and Driver B’s speed or driving behavior.
- Traffic Camera Footage:
- Traffic cameras or nearby security footage may provide a clearer picture of the light signals, traffic flow, and the actions of both Driver A and Driver B.
- Dashcam Footage:
- Dashcam footage from either Driver A or Driver B could show the exact moment of the collision and help determine fault based on timing, speed, and the traffic conditions.
- Expert Testimony:
- An accident reconstruction expert could testify about the timing, speed, and positioning of both vehicles before the collision. This would help determine whether Driver A’s turn was unsafe or if Driver B was speeding or engaged in other reckless behavior.
⚖️ Comparative Negligence in California
California follows the pure comparative negligence rule. This means that if both drivers are found to share some responsibility for the accident, the damages awarded to the injured party will be reduced according to their percentage of fault. For example:
- If Driver A is found 40% at fault (for turning left without ensuring it was safe) and Driver B is found 60% at fault (for speeding or driving recklessly), then the injured party can still recover 60% of their damages, but their award would be reduced by 40% due to their own share of the fault.
🚨 Possible Defenses Driver B Might Use
- Driver A’s Failure to Yield:
- Driver B could argue that Driver A failed to yield the right of way when making a left turn, which directly caused the crash. This defense would be especially strong if Driver A failed to check oncoming traffic or didn’t allow enough time to clear the intersection.
- Speeding or Recklessness of Driver A:
- If Driver A was turning in a reckless manner (e.g., speeding through the turn, making a wide turn across multiple lanes), Driver B might argue that Driver A’s behavior was the primary cause of the crash.
- Driver B’s Speeding or Recklessness:
- If Driver B was speeding, running a red light, or distracted, they could be primarily at fault for the crash. This would shift the responsibility away from Driver A if Driver B was not following the rules of the road.
🚗 Next Steps for the Injured Party
If you are the injured party, here are the steps to take next:
- Document the Scene: Take photos of the accident scene, including the vehicles, traffic signs, and road conditions. Note any traffic signals or construction zone hazards that may have affected the crash.
- File an Insurance Claim: File a claim with Driver B’s insurance company for the damage and medical costs. Be sure to keep track of all related expenses.
- Consult with a Lawyer: If liability is disputed, or if the insurance company offers a low settlement, consider consulting with an attorney to help negotiate a fair settlement or file a personal injury lawsuit.
- Gather Medical Records: Collect all relevant medical records to document the severity of your injuries. These will be critical in proving pain and suffering, as well as future medical costs.
Law Offices of James R. Dickinson – 909-848-8448
How To Schedule A Consultation:
Please call us at 909-848-8448 to schedule a free consultation/case evaluation or complete the form immediately below. [Please note certain formalities must be completed to retain the Law Offices of James R. Dickinson, such as the signing of a legal fee agreement [see “Disclaimers”]].