In a California personal injury case involving items falling from high shelves in a retail store, the store may be held liable under premises liability law if a customer is injured as a result. Retailers have a legal duty to ensure that merchandise is safely stored and secured, especially when displayed or stocked above head level.
⚖️ Legal Framework: California Civil Code § 1714
California law requires store owners and managers to exercise reasonable care to prevent dangerous conditions that could injure customers. This includes:
- Safely stacking items on high shelves
- Avoiding overstocking or unstable arrangements
- Using brackets, barriers, or netting to secure merchandise
- Training staff on safe stocking procedures
Failure to do so may result in negligence and financial liability for injuries.
✅ Legal Elements You Must Prove
To win a personal injury claim for injuries caused by falling merchandise, you must establish the following:
1. Duty of Care
Retailers owe customers a duty to:
- Maintain safe conditions on store shelves
- Ensure merchandise is not precariously stacked
- Conduct regular inspections
2. Breach of Duty
The store may breach this duty if:
- Employees improperly stocked merchandise on high shelves
- Items were overstacked or hung insecurely
- They failed to install safety restraints (e.g., brackets, lips, or fencing)
- There were no warning signs in areas where items could fall
3. Causation
You must show that the falling item was the direct cause of your injury, such as:
- A box fell and struck you on the head or shoulder
- A heavy object hit your foot or caused you to fall
4. Damages
You must demonstrate that you suffered actual harm:
- Medical expenses
- Lost income
- Pain and suffering
- Long-term injuries or disability
🔍 Evidence to Support Your Case
📸 1. Photos and Videos
- Show the item that fell, its size/weight, and the shelf it came from
- Document whether shelves were overstocked or lacked safety features
📝 2. Incident Report
- File one with store management and request a copy
👥 3. Witness Testimony
- Witnesses may verify that the item fell without any provocation or that stocking was unsafe
🎥 4. Surveillance Footage
- Stores often have cameras covering aisles—request this footage promptly
🧾 5. Maintenance or Stocking Logs
- These may show a lack of inspections, improper storage practices, or past similar incidents
🏥 6. Medical Records
- Include emergency care, follow-up treatment, diagnosis, and prognosis
🛡️ Common Defenses the Store May Raise
❌ “Unforeseeable Event”
They may argue the fall was unpredictable or due to customer interference. This is weak if:
- The item was stacked in a visibly unsafe way
- The store had prior notice of the risk or similar incidents
❌ “Comparative Negligence”
The store may claim you pulled or bumped the shelf. Under California’s pure comparative fault rule, your compensation can be reduced based on your share of fault.
Example:
- Damages = $80,000
- You are 25% at fault
- You recover $60,000
🗓️ Statute of Limitations
- 2 years from the date of injury to file a personal injury lawsuit in California
Law Offices of James R. Dickinson – 909-848-8448
How To Schedule A Consultation:
Please call us at 909-848-8448 to schedule a free consultation/case evaluation or complete the form immediately below. [Please note certain formalities must be completed to retain the Law Offices of James R. Dickinson, such as the signing of a legal fee agreement [see “Disclaimers”]].