Spouses may agree to hire one neutral expert to value a business, pension, residence, or other disputed asset. A joint expert can reduce cost and simplify the case, but the arrangement should clearly define the expert’s role before work begins.
One Expert Can Reduce Duplication
Hiring separate experts can require the spouses to pay for two investigations, two reports, and competing testimony. A joint expert reviews the information once and provides an opinion to both sides.
This approach may work well when the financial issue is relatively straightforward and the spouses can agree on the records, valuation date, and questions the expert must address.
The Assignment Must Be Defined
The spouses should agree on the scope of the expert’s work, access to records, communications, payment, and deadline for the report. If one spouse later wants the expert to perform additional analysis, approval from the other spouse may be required.
The agreement should also address whether the expert may communicate separately with either side. Communications with a jointly retained expert generally do not receive the same confidentiality protection as communications with a private consulting expert.
The Report Is Not Automatically Evidence
The spouses may stipulate that the joint expert’s report can be admitted at a hearing or trial, subject to cross-examination. Without such an agreement, a written expert report may not be admissible by itself.
A party relying on the opinion may need to call the expert to testify about qualifications, methods, assumptions, and conclusions. The party challenging the opinion may also need to pay for cross-examination or retain another expert.
A Joint Expert Is Not Appropriate in Every Case
Separate experts may be more appropriate when the spouses disagree substantially about facts, assumptions, access to financial information, or the proper valuation method. If one expert cannot fairly resolve the disputed issues, the court may permit each spouse to retain their own expert.
The spouses should not assume that selecting a joint expert makes the final opinion binding. The effect of the opinion depends on their agreement and the court’s evaluation of the evidence.
A California divorce attorney can draft the joint-expert agreement, define the assignment, preserve cross-examination rights, and assess whether one neutral expert will truly reduce cost without weakening the client’s ability to challenge an unreliable opinion.


Comments are closed