In a California personal injury case involving spilled beverages in a café or food court located inside a retail store or shopping mall, the legal framework is again based on premises liability. However, these cases may involve multiple potentially responsible parties (e.g., the retail store, a food vendor, or the property owner), depending on the setup.
Here’s how California law typically applies and what you’d need to prove:
⚖️ Legal Framework: Premises Liability in Shared Retail Spaces
Under California Civil Code § 1714, property owners, tenants, and business operators have a duty to exercise reasonable care in maintaining safe premises for customers. This applies to:
- Individual food vendors (e.g., Starbucks, Panda Express)
- The main retailer (e.g., Target, Costco)
- The shopping mall or property management company (if applicable)
When beverages are spilled and not cleaned up, any party responsible for the area could be liable if a customer slips and is injured.
✅ Elements of a Slip-and-Fall Claim
To win a personal injury case in California, the injured person must prove:
1. Duty of Care
The defendant (vendor/store/mall) owed a duty to keep the area safe for patrons.
2. Breach of Duty
They breached that duty by:
- Failing to clean up a spilled beverage
- Not placing a “Wet Floor” sign or barrier
- Not inspecting the area regularly
- Failing to train employees to address spills quickly
3. Causation
The spill directly caused the customer to slip and fall.
4. Damages
The fall resulted in actual injuries (e.g., medical bills, lost wages, pain and suffering).
🔍 Constructive vs. Actual Knowledge
You must show the responsible party knew or should have known about the spill:
- Actual knowledge: An employee saw the spill and ignored it.
- Constructive knowledge: The spill had been there long enough that a reasonable employee should have discovered it during routine inspections.
Courts look at:
- Length of time the liquid was on the floor
- Frequency of inspections
- Whether staff were in the vicinity
- Store policies and whether they were followed
🔑 Evidence That Can Strengthen Your Claim
- Photos or video of the spill and surrounding area
- Surveillance footage showing the spill and fall
- Witness testimony (other customers, employees)
- Incident report from store or vendor
- Medical records showing injuries
- Store/vendor cleaning logs or inspection records
🛡️ Common Defenses by the Store or Vendor
The business may argue:
- The spill happened just before the fall, and they had no chance to clean it.
- The customer was not paying attention or wore unsafe footwear.
- Warning signs were present, even if the plaintiff didn’t see them.
- The area was under another vendor’s control, not theirs.
⚠️ Comparative Negligence in California
California uses pure comparative negligence:
- If the injured person is partly at fault, their damages are reduced proportionally.
- Example: $100,000 in damages reduced to $70,000 if you’re 30% at fault.
🏛️ Multiple Potentially Liable Parties
Slip-and-fall incidents in food courts or retail cafés may involve shared responsibility. Possible defendants include:
- The vendor (e.g., Starbucks) — if it occurred inside their leased space
- The retailer — if they own and operate the café or didn’t maintain the shared space
- The mall owner or property manager — if it happened in a common area (e.g., seating area, shared hallway)
Determining who had control over the area where the spill occurred is critical.
🗓️ Statute of Limitations
- 2 years from the date of injury to file a personal injury lawsuit in California.
📋 What to Do Immediately After the Fall
- Take photos of the scene (spill, surroundings, lack of signage)
- Get contact info for any witnesses
- Report the incident to store or vendor management and request a written report
- Seek medical treatment and save records
- Preserve clothing and footwear worn at the time of the fall
- Consult a premises liability attorney
Law Offices of James R. Dickinson – 909-848-8448
How To Schedule A Consultation:
Please call us at 909-848-8448 to schedule a free consultation/case evaluation or complete the form immediately below. [Please note certain formalities must be completed to retain the Law Offices of James R. Dickinson, such as the signing of a legal fee agreement [see “Disclaimers”]].