A child custody recommending counselor’s report may contain information relevant to a DVRO involving the same parents or children. The report is confidential, and its admissibility depends on evidentiary requirements rather than its mere existence in the family-law file.
The Counselor May Be Called to Testify
A custody recommending counselor may be required to appear and answer questions about the report and the information gathered.
Live testimony may help authenticate the report, explain the counselor’s process, and address disputed statements or conclusions.
The Report May Qualify as an Official Record
The report may be admitted without the counselor’s testimony when it satisfies the requirements applicable to official records.
Admission is not automatic. The party seeking to use the report should formally offer it and establish the necessary basis for the court to consider it.
Statements Within the Report Need Separate Analysis
A parent’s statement in the report may be admissible when offered by the opposing parent. Statements from teachers, relatives, children, or other interviewed people may present additional hearsay issues.
Each third-party statement may require its own exception before it can be considered for the truth of what it asserts. Admission of the report does not necessarily make every sentence admissible.
The Report Must Remain Confidential
Custody recommending counselor reports are confidential and should not be filed in the public court record.
The parties should use the report only as authorized and should request appropriate handling of sensitive information. Confidentiality does not eliminate the respondent’s right to review and answer evidence used against them.
A California DVRO attorney can assess whether the custody report is helpful, obtain the counselor’s testimony when necessary, and address embedded hearsay. Counsel can also ensure that the report is presented without improperly placing confidential custody information in the public record.


Comments are closed