A child’s statement about domestic violence may sometimes be used when the child does not testify. The statement is not automatically admissible, and the party offering it must address authentication, hearsay, and the circumstances in which the statement was made.
The Statement Must Be Authenticated
A parent or another person familiar with the statement and its surrounding circumstances may provide the foundation necessary to identify it.
Relevant evidence may include an emergency call, recording, text message, police report, or a report made to a teacher, doctor, or other adult.
Spontaneous Statements May Be Admissible
A child’s description made while witnessing an incident or shortly afterward may qualify under an exception for spontaneous statements.
The court examines whether the statement was made under the stress of the event rather than after time for reflection or coaching. The child’s age does not automatically prevent the exception from applying.
Legal Unavailability Is Narrow
A witness is not legally unavailable merely because testifying would be inconvenient or uncomfortable. The applicable exception generally requires a recognized circumstance such as death, lack of subpoena power, or a present witness who refuses to testify.
Other exceptions may apply even when the child is not legally unavailable. The purpose for which the statement is offered also matters.
The Child’s Welfare Requires Consideration
Courts and parents should consider the potential harm of requiring a child to testify against a parent. Judges may also be concerned about coaching or the effect of testimony on future custody proceedings.
A child’s confidential information should not be unnecessarily placed in the public record. Any existing custody or protective order remains binding during the evidentiary dispute.
A California DVRO attorney can identify a valid evidentiary basis for the child’s statement, establish its authenticity, and seek appropriate confidentiality protections. Counsel can also explore other evidence that may avoid requiring the child to testify.


Comments are closed